mocoNews.net - Unhealthily Obsessed with Mobile Content

Current Story

Google Algorithm In Need Of Serious Overhaul For Mobile Web?

By Dianne See Morrison - Thu 10 Jan 2008 06:02 AM PST

Much has been written about Google (NSDQ: GOOG) and its proposed mobile operating system Android. USA Today has a long feature article looking at what’s driving the mobile web and concludes that in the scramble for the advertising and e-commerce dollars that will inevitably migrate from online to mobile web, Google’s mobile operating system play is all about Google trying to keep its grip on consumers “under the guise that the wireless industry isn’t providing an open environment for applications”.

It’s not a particularly new conclusion, but the article also quotes Dan Olschwang, CEO of start up JumpTap, which has developed a search engine and search advertising platform for mobiles, as saying Google’s problem isn’t the lack of an open operating system for mobile devices, but that the internet search behemoth’s basic search algorithm will need a “serious” overhaul if its going to serve mobile users. Olschwang noted: “If somebody asks, ‘Where is the closest gas station?’ they need that information now, and they don’t need 20,000 results.” He concluded that while Google won’t “completely fail”, it won’t be “nearly as successful as they are on the (desktop) Web”.

Moreover, it looks like network operators are still skittish as to how much advertising a subscriber is willing to take. USA Today quotes T-Mobile’s chief development officer Cole Brodman as saying the network will not “blanket its customers with advertisements from Google or any other company”. Brodman added: “Mobile phones are personal and private, and we want to ensure that we are speaking for the consumer in terms of any advertising…Just getting blasted with search results and banner advertising is not something most consumers will accept.”

Posted in: Companies, Google, Operators, T-Mobile, Mobile Adv & Mktg, Mobile Search


Related Research from Alacrastore.com

5 Responses:
  • From Ajay Thu 10 Jan 2008 08:00 AM

    Come on, No point in bashing google for unnecessary things. First thing google is going to come up is using that GPS serve you gas station or what ever closet to you that’s why Andriod is open on Maps and mashups. T-Mobile is good enough in its place but hey they do not serve the handset and that is core play of Andriod so they would not control what google servers or not.

    People are still in denial or try to make other’s opinion in denial is such stupid. I did not see a single great product from USA or Gannet on Mobile. No 4info is not a great product ((at least for me)). Andriod is going to be superb as per as app. base goes. What i suspect is only prob in adoption with data plan but for that we have to wait and see how it is played out.

  • From Miguel Thu 10 Jan 2008 09:16 AM

    Misinformation much? If you actually do try to search for “gas station” in googles mobile site

    http://www.google.com/m/search?mrestrict=xhtmlonly&q=gas+stations

    you’re then greeted with a location box. Key in your zip code and there you have it, a list of nearby gas stations. Click on one to get a map. 3 steps and you have something you want.

    As Ajay said, with Andriod you don’t even have to enter your zip code.

    In all fairness, Yahoo’s oneSearch can do this also.

  • From rose Thu 10 Jan 2008 09:02 PM

    Miguel, you can try http://www.bywifi.com. It provides better mobile transcoded result for internet web pages.

  • From Magnus Jern Fri 11 Jan 2008 11:03 AM

    Probably depends on what country your in as well. In the UK, Spain or Germany you get completely pointless results if you search for gas station:
    http://www.google.co.uk/m/search?mrestrict=xhtml&q=gas+station&site=mobile

    Try searching for a mobile game or ringtone. Last time I searched for games I ended up on a web page with flash games which don’t work on my mobile and then on a ringtone page on the web where I could input my phone number which then directed me to a WAP-page which was 3 extra steps rather than just giving me a mobile ringtones page. I don’t understand how anyone can object to the fact that google mobile currently provides terrible and irrelevant results.

  • From Julie Zbeetnoff Wed 16 Jan 2008 02:15 PM

    “Try searching for a mobile game or ringtone. Last time I searched for games I ended up on a web page with flash games which don’t work on my mobile”

    In my humble opinion it would be benificial for Google to come up with a mobile optimized only search index for mobile web users or at least a clear specification per search listing if and or how compatable a site is for mobile browsing.

    Personally I support the .mobi standards for mobile publishing. I can see this as becoming an intuitive choice for people searching for info with their mobile phones as .mobi pages.

Post Your Comment

Mobile Options

» Mobile App
» Mobile/WAP Site

Send a News Tip

About

mocoNews.net is a news site covering the business of mobile content.

Rafat Ali
Publisher & Co-Editor

Staci D. Kramer
Co-Editor

Tricia Duryee
Principal Correspondent

Matt Kapko
Senior Entertainment Reporter

Dianne See Morrison
Contributing Writer

James Quintana Pearce
Contributing Writer

Robert Andrews
U.K. Editor

EconCeleb Conference - The Economics of Celebrity. July 23 at the Roosevelt Hotel in Hollywood

Featured Report - 2008 Social Media Deals Report

front page of report

The economics of social media continue to heat up, with ever more buzz created in new and growing market categories. This report examines the categories, number and size of investment and acquisitions into social media and the resulting value created from 2007 through 2008. Order your report today to analyze deals made by Yahoo, Disney, Google, AOL, CBS, Hearst, Microsoft and many more.

Learn more or purchase now.

New Media/Interactive Job Listings

Post Job
More Jobs

Generous Supporters